+
Pro-Coast Outcome
-
Anti-Coast Outcome

All Issues

Sonoma Coast Parking Fees
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2016

California’s Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR) continued to push its plan to implement new fees at gravel parking lots in very rural stretches of the Sonoma coast. This was the second hearing before the Coastal Commission on DPR’s proposal...

Issue:Strands Settlement Agreement & Cease and Desist Order
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2016

This case began in 2009 when the City of Dana Point adopted ordinances that restricted coastal access to the Strand Beach access areas. The hours that the City decided upon to allow public access were enforced by the installation of gates...

Amending Clause to Interim Executive Director Appointment
-
+

Meeting Date:

March 1, 2016

As well vocalized by many public speakers at the March Coastal Commission hearing, deciding upon an interim Executive Director is not a position that the public desired...

Rancho Palos Verdes Permit Only Parking
-
+

Meeting Date:

March 1, 2016

An issue of convenience for street residents or access for all, this appeal was filed because the locally approved development of permit only parking for Channelview Court was found to be inconsistent with both the Local Coastal Program...

Consideration of Dismissal of the Executive Director
-
+

Meeting Date:

February 1, 2016

Morro Bay was host to significant and dramatic events during the Wednesday, Feb. 10 Coastal Commission hearing, in which the fate of Executive Director Charles Lester was decided. An estimated 1,000 people turned out to support Dr. Lester's continued tenure with the Coastal Commission and to demand a transparent, responsible process...

Solana Beach Sea Cave Fill-in
-
+

Meeting Date:

January 1, 2016

This project would have involved maintaining and expanding the five existing sea cave infills with an additional 75-foot long notch in the coastal bluff. According to the applicant, the action was not currently critical to the structures on the coastal bluff...

Fred Segal Foundation Cease and Desist and Restoration Orders
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2015

Since the purchase of the property in the early 1980s, the Fred Segal Foundation property has had a number of unpermitted developments including: the unpermitted subdivision of the lot; unpermitted placement of structures and infrastructure...

The Edge Development
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2015

The proposal originally sought to develop several homes at least 10,000 square feet in size for the last decade in an otherwise undeveloped area of Malibu. During this time, environmental advocates fought the development. Through their efforts...

USC’s Catalina Aquaculture Project
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2015

The University of Southern California Wrigley Institute for Environmental Studies (USC-WIES) applied for a permit to install and operate a shellfish aquaculture research facility for five years within a state-designated Marine Protected Area...

SFPUC Ocean Beach Temporary Erosion Management
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2015

This CDP is to temporarily allow the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) to use “soft structures” to help with erosion control at Ocean Beach over the next six years while preparing to implement the long-term managed retreat solution to the erosion threat...

Silver Shoals Development
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2015

The Silver Shoals development item had previously appeared in front of the Commission as a project, but had been returned to Staff with substantial issue. This housing development will occur along the Coast Highway – a section of the highway...

Broad Beach
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2015

The Broad Beach Geologic Hazard Abatement District applied for authorization of a 4,150 ft revetment, moving a portion of the revetment landward, an attempt at dune restoration using the revetment as the dune-base, and a beach nourishment program...

Lido House Hotel
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2015

The site of the former Newport Beach City Hall is the location of the proposed Lido House Hotel. This project would turn the former government building into a 4 story, 130 room high-cost hotel with retail and parking space. General practice...

Sea World Orca Enclosure Expansion
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2015

Sea World submitted a coastal development permit application to build larger orca tanks at its San Diego facility. This project involves expansion of its current orca facility by replacing it with a new 450,000-gallon and a 5.2 million gallon pool...

Big Lagoon Park
-
+

Meeting Date:

September 1, 2015

This application was for a redesignation and rezoning of portions of a 13-acre parcel to allow for relocation of 14 cabins away from the parcel’s bluff. The modifications to the amendment include the point that there will be no resulting increase...

Malibu Coast Estate / Crummer Trust Property
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2015

This application, by the City of Malibu, was a project-driven Local Coastal Plan amendment for a zoning change from visitor serving use to non-visitor serving for a parcel located at the terminus of Malibu Canyon Drive and next to Bluffs Park...

San Diego Unified Port District Port Master Plan Amendment
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2015

This application for the Port of San Diego’s Port Master Plan Amendment (PMPA) would revise the current plan which allows for one single, high quality hotel to allow for the development of up to three separate hotels with a combined total of 500 rooms...

South Kellogg Recycling Facility
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2015

This CDP application was for an unpermitted concrete/asphalt recycling facility. As stated in the Commission Staff report, the facility began operating in 2010 but had not filed for a permit till December 2011. Commission Staff observed...

Drakes Estero Wilderness Federal Consistency Determination
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2015

The Point Reyes National Seashore (Seashore) submitted a consistency determination to the Commission to remove shellfish debris and infrastructure in Drakes Estero Wilderness area. The Seashore proposed to remove 95 pressure-treated wood...

Monterey Bay Shores Resort 2
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2015

The Commission held a lengthy hearing regarding the CDP application to build a ten-story, 368 unit luxury condo and hotel complex on 39 acres of coastal sand dunes in Sand City (Monterey County). The project was conditionally approved...

Sharp Park
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2015

San Francisco Recreation and Parks Department (SFRPD) submitted an application for infrastructure improvements at Sharp Park Golf Course including after-the-fact permit approval of pump replacements, sediment dredging and emergent vegetation ...

Sonoma Coast State Park Fees
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2015

The Department of Parks and Recreation (the Department) is seeking to install pay stations at 15 locations along the Sonoma Coast. In 2013, the Department submitted a proposal to the Board of Supervisors to install the pay stations...

Bay City Partners LLC Development
-
+

Meeting Date:

March 1, 2015

This project is uniquely located along the San Gabriel River and adjacent to the ocean in Seal Beach. The application includes ‘subdivision and sale’ of 32 residential lots, a 6.4 acre park, a public easement over a bike bath, and access to parking...

Black Hill Villas
-
+

Meeting Date:

February 1, 2015

A proposal to subdivide two parcels into 17 residential parcels and one common area, and to construct 17 single-family residences with two-car garages, two of which would be built to City of Morro Bay standards for affordable units. The proposed...

“The Ranch” Laguna Beach
-
+

Meeting Date:

January 1, 2015

Located in the coastal foothills of Laguna Beach, this Project includes an expansion of a 64-room hotel, restaurant, and golf course to include an additional 33 hotel rooms; reconfiguration of restaurant; additions to existing structures ...

Navy Silver Strand Development Project
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2014

The US Navy proposed a major development consisting of 24 separate projects and 1.5 million square feet of new facilities to be constructed over a ten-year period at its Silver Strand Base in San Diego County...

Cabrillo Power I LLC Dredging Project
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2014

Cabrillo Power submitted an application for a permit to dredge 500,000 cubic yards of sand from the bottom of the Agua Hedionda Lagoon and deposit the dredged sand on North, Middle, and South Beach in Carlsbad...

Crystal Cove State Park Interpretive Center
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2014

California State Parks proposed to remove an existing Interpretive Center from a parking lot at Crystal Cove State Park and build two new modular structures in Environmentally Sensitive Habitat...

Hitzke Mixed-Use Development
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2014

The permit application was for construction of a mixed-use building including commercial office space, 10 low-income housing units, and improvements to parking, landscaping, and sidewalk...

Bay City Partner’s Appeal of Executive Director Determination
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2014

This vote was not based on the merits of the proposed project, but whether the project application is complete. Commission Staff deemed the application incomplete and the Applicant appealed Staff’s decision. While the Commission was not...

City of San Diego Local Coastal Program Amendment Regarding Children’s Pool
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2014

The City of San Diego sought to revise public access and marine resource protection policies in its Land Use Plan (LUP) to allow a seasonal closure at Children’s Pool Beach in La Jolla during the Harbor Seal pupping season (from December 15 to May 15 of every year)...

Ocean Trails- The Trump Organization
-
+

Meeting Date:

July 1, 2014

The application included a request to amend the current permit to reconfigure 26 residential lots and two golf course lots resulting in reduced residential density. As part of the changes to the original permit, the Trump Organization also sought...

Ontario Ridge Trail Cease and Desist Order
-
+

Meeting Date:

July 1, 2014

The Commission heard a Cease and Desist Order regarding illegal fencing, gates, and no trespassing signs blocking public access at Ontario Ridge Trail. This heavily visited hiking trail on the San Luis Obispo County coast, has been used...

Bannasch Living Trust sea cave-notch fill
-
+

Meeting Date:

June 1, 2014

The applicants in this case chose to rebuild their home in 1991 and place it within the 40 foot setback zone just 29 feet from the bluff edge. In exchange, they waived their right to a future seawall through a deed restriction but were allowed...

Carr Cabana Appeal
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2014

This was an appeal by Commissioners Zimmer and Bochco regarding the approval of a permit in the Hope Ranch area of Santa Barbara County. The property in question is a bluff-top estate with several pre-Coastal Act non-conforming structures...

Marin LCP Update
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2014

The County of Marin proposed extensive changes to its existing Local Coastal Program (LCP)’s Land Use Plan (LUP). The process leading up to the Commission’s May hearing regarding the amendments was elaborate and lengthy—lasting nearly 5 years...

Monterey Bay Shores Resort
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2014

On April 9th, the Commission devoted 10 hours to an application by Ed Ghandour – Security National Guarantee Inc. (SNG), to build a ten-story, 368 unit luxury condo and hotel complex on 39 acres of coastal sand dunes in Sand City, (Monterey County)...

Paradiso del Mare Development
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2014

On April 9th, the Commission heard an appeal on two large-scale residential estates, approved by Santa Barbara County on the Gaviota coast. The proposed project would be constructed on sensitive coastal habitat that is home to special status...

Santa Monica Mountains Land Use Plan
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2014

On April 10th, the Coastal Commission reviewed the Land Use Plan submitted by the County of Los Angeles for the unincorporated area of the Santa Monica Mountains (SMM), in the coastal zone. Without a certified LCP, the Commission...

Studio OneEleven – Long Beach Motel
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2014

On April 11th, the Commission unanimously denied a Coastal Development Permit for the demolition of a 40 unit (low-moderate cost) motel for the construction of a seven level 72 room hotel and up to 33 residential condo units in Long Beach...

Local Coastal Program Grant Awards for Fiscal Year 2013-2014
-
+

Meeting Date:

January 1, 2014

In 2013, the Governor and Legislature provided the Commission with $1 million to distribute grants to local governments to support Local Coastal Program (LCP) planning. In August 2013 the Commission adopted funding criteria, stating...

Solana Beach Land Use Plan Amendment
-
+

Meeting Date:

January 1, 2014

In November 2013, the City of Solana Beach brought forward amendments to its Land Use Plan (LUP). The Commission denied certification at that time and continued the hearing. At the January hearing, the City returned with LUP amendments...

Pismo Beach Seawall – Army Corps of Engineers
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2013

In January 2013, the CCC approved a permit for construction of a seawall at St. Andrews sewage pumping station in Pismo Beach. That permit required the Corps or City to return to the Commission in five years with a managed retreat plan...

22nd District Agricultural Association (Del Mar Fairgrounds)
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2013

The Del Mar Fairgrounds applied for year-round parking lot on a wetland site where they admitted to previously illegally filling and grading...

Huntington Beach Poseidon Desalination Proposal
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2013

Poseidon Water proposed to build a 50 million gallon per day (MGD) seawater desalination plant to be co-located with the AES Power Plant in Huntington Beach. The plan would be equivalent in size to the largest desalination plant in the Western Hemisphere...

Strategic Plan Subcommittee Reports
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2013

Commission action on two reports from their Strategic Plan Subcommittee to define the level of reporting by the Executive Director on Strategic Plan implementation (metrics & milestones)...

Gordon Encinitas Staircase
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2013

Appeal by Commissioners Mitchell and Brennan of CDP issued by the City of Encinitas to applicant that would include retention and removal of portions of an unpermitted private stairway leading from the blufftop to the beach; replacement ...

Romney House
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2013

The City of San Diego to demolish an existing 3,009 square foot residence and construct a new 11,062 square foot, two-story over basement single-family residence with attached 4-car garage, hardscape, and retaining walls, with existing pool, spa, and seawall...

San Diego Convention Center Expansion
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2013

A 740,000 sq. ft. expansion of the San Diego Convention Center with a 5-acre rooftop park and construction of a new Hilton Hotel Tower with 500 rooms, 55,000 sq. ft. of meeting-ballroom space...

Eureka – Arcata Route 101 Corridor Improvement Project
-
+

Meeting Date:

September 1, 2013

Application in Humboldt County to increase safety at six intersections and to improve roadway in order to meet current design standards...